Serious investment thinking that doesn’t take itself too seriously.

HOME

LOGIN

ABOUT THE CURIOUS INVESTOR GROUP

SUBSCRIBE

SIGN UP TO THE WEEKLY

PARTNERS

TESTIMONIALS

CONTRIBUTORS

CONTACT US

MAGAZINE ARCHIVE

PRIVACY POLICY

SEARCH

-- CATEGORIES --

GREEN CHRONICLE

PODCASTS

THE AGENT

ALTERNATIVE ASSETS

THE ANALYST

THE ARCHITECT

ASTROPHYSIST

THE AUCTIONEER

THE ECONOMIST

EDITORIAL NOTES

FACE TO FACE

THE FARMER

THE FUND MANAGER

THE GUEST ESSAY

THE HEAD HUNTER

HEAD OF RESEARCH

THE HISTORIAN

INVESTORS NOTEBOOK

THE MACRO VIEW

POLITICAL INSIDER

THE PROFESSOR

PROP NOTES

RESIDENTIAL INVESTOR

TECHNOLOGY

UNCORKED

Mind the bank-shaped gap

by | Jul 6, 2017

The Fund Manager

Mind the bank-shaped gap

by | Jul 6, 2017

It is almost a decade since the beginning of the end of the debt-driven property boom. Back then, British banks supplied 72% of the finance to the market, Germans and CMBS supplied most of the remainder, and little else could compete.

Anyone returning from ten years on a desert island would be amazed at the diversification of debt supply in the intervening period, and broad cast of ‘property lenders’ at your service. Our list of would-be debt investors is well over 400 strong. International banks, insurers, pension and sovereign wealth funds are joined by a host of opportunistic investors – hedge funds, family offices and peer to peer lenders seeking route to market via a wide range of debt fund platforms and strategies. Regulators must be delighted by the reduction in systemic risk to banks from UK CRE.

The ‘regional problem’ summarised

It therefore surprised me to see latest statistics on transacted lending show less diversity than ever in the distribution of debt, with only 37% of lending deployed outside London and the South East, reducing steadily year by year from 58% in 2010 (source: De Montfort University UK Commercial Property Lending Market 2016).

This is out of kilter with strong investment activity in the regions, where turnover in the past three years exceeded 2005-7 (see chart below), and the referendum dampened turnover by only 12% compared to more than 30% across the whole UK market (source: PropertyData.com, Jan 2017).


Used with permission

Nor can this be attributed to London’s bulging super-prime equity pricing – since the majority Asian buyers ignore secured lending, leaving lenders with a diminishing stock of prime real estate to fund (to their chagrin).

Requests for finance that we track through the Laxfield CRE Debt Market Barometer show an even London/regional split, so the evidence points a failure in lending (however diversified) to match regional liquidity needs.

Operating in an ‘equity glut’, there has, to date, been no perceptible value impact caused by this imbalance. In more constrained conditions, it has potential to de-stabilise the market.

The borrower’s perspective

On the ground, the story varies. Dominant regional propcos with large investment portfolios have no difficulty using these to finance development activities. Sitting in the core client category of the banks, and with additional access to long term institutional funding, they have strengthened their position in the past few years.

By contrast, an entrepreneur with good ideas for creating value from one unloved asset at a time needs an exceptionally high pain threshold to get through bank processes, where they are not considered a core customer. Building societies no longer finance ‘building’ either.

Most turn at this point to alternative finance, but two main barriers exist to efficient matching:

  1. Without a branch network, debt funds struggle to take their offering far and wide, and simply don’t have boots on the ground in many markets outside London. The variety and complexity of the debt offer in the market is hard for borrowers to navigate. In other words, deals and lenders aren’t finding each other easily enough.
  2. Price: most debt funds need substantial yield. A barbell of debt capital exists with lots of risk averse senior debt at one end (bound by protective regulation), and multiple yield hungry offerings at the other. To borrow often requires such a profit giveaway that it challenges the viability of many schemes.

The Brexit landscape has exaggerated this polarisation of the lending market, and financing small lot sizes, single assets with leasing risk and ground-up development has been thrown to the right of the barbell, becoming a fight with the lender to extract value.

There is little prospect that the bank branch network will revert to the range of activities it covered in the past, and solve the regional problem, particularly as their largest write downs were suffered on over-leveraged secondary regional properties.

Alternative response

The market response needed for a restoration of balance needs to come from new and/or alternative lenders, possibly finding more localised solutions outside London, direct to the thirstier parts of the market.

If debt investors and managers can adjust their model to modify returns and promote accretive funding products, they should be paid well for moderate risk, and find themselves refreshingly welcome and able to deploy at speed.

About Emma Huepfl

About Emma Huepfl

Emma Huepfl is a Founder and Co-Principal of Laxfield Capital, an investment management business specialising in real estate debt. With more than 25 years’ experience in UK CRE debt markets, she has overseen more than £10bn of debt deals. In 2015 she founded Laxfield National, aiming to address imbalances in regional and mid-market funding. She is a board member of the Commercial Real Estate Finance Council of Europe and authors the bi-annual Laxfield CRE Debt Market Barometer, analysing changing finance demand from a pool of more than £110bn of loan requests.

INVESTOR'S NOTEBOOK

Smart people from around the world share their thoughts

READ MORE >

THE MACRO VIEW

Recent financial news and how it connects across all asset classes

READ MORE >

TECHNOLOGY

Fintech, proptech and what it all means

READ MORE >

PODCASTS

Engaging conversations with strategic thinkers

READ MORE >

THE ARCHITECT

Some of the profession’s best minds

READ MORE >

RESIDENTIAL ADVISOR

Making money from residential property investment

READ MORE >

THE PROFESSOR

Analysis and opinion from the academic sphere

READ MORE >

FACE-TO-FACE

In-depth interviews with leading figures in the real estate/investment world.

READ MORE >