Do foreign investors know something we don’t? – The Property Chronicle
Select your region of interest:

Real estate, alternative real assets and other diversions

Do foreign investors know something we don’t? Our capital markets analyst gives his thoughts on the latest trends in mergers and acquisitions

The Analyst

Abstract view of candlestick charts

Image (c) iStockphoto

Do foreign investors know something we don’t?

Since the Brexit vote last June we have seen a number of assets snapped up by foreign investors, driven in part by the weakness of sterling since the referendum. In the past few weeks Cannon Place was acquired by Deka for £485m, although admittedly it was sold by Hines. According to Cluttons the proportion of international investment in the London office sector reached 80% in the 1Q of this year, up from 59% last year. Indeed, it seems investment in the 1Q may have been at record breaking levels.

However, what we hadn’t seen until recently was acquisitions of listed property companies. It is true that Shaftesbury has been in play for a while, as Samuel Tak Lee has built up an 18% stake in the company. But last week we saw takeovers of two UK listed property companies launched on the same day (if we ignore the fact that the Market Tech deal slipped out on the previous Friday evening).

KW offer for KWE feels like a missed opportunity

Starting with the bigger of the two, KW Holdings launched a recommended offer for Kennedy Wilson Europe, which it already managed and had a c.24% stake in. It is being structured as a merger, but KWE shareholders will only have a 36% stake in the NYSE listed parent at the end of the process. The most interesting part of the deal for me was that even after offering £1.5bn, a 20% premium to the prevailing share price, the offer for KWE was still pitched at a 3.4% discount to the last reported NAV. KWE shareholders will receive two dividends which will narrow this discount, but they would have received those anyway.

This strikes me as a failure for the UK market. The KWE IPO was only 3 years ago and it raised £1bn to invest in European real estate and real estate loans. I have to admit I found it less interesting because of its credit focus, but the returns were good to start with (18% NAV total return in 2015). They slowed last year to less than 8% and it has traded at a wide discount, in line with the larger listed REITs, as the market waned.

Clearly KW has broader corporate reasons for acquiring KWE. It wants to build a global portfolio, with a wider market presence and access to capital and acquisition opportunities. Not to mention the potential synergies and earnings enhancement. So perhaps it is worth more to KW than to other investors. However, you could argue that KWE as a listed entity is a victim of the market’s short termism, trading at a wide discount, because of a perceived turn in the market cycle. Mind you, some of those investors are going to have decide what to do with the NYSE listed stock they will end up with, so perhaps that will cure them of that particular affliction.

The KWE takeover may not run smoothly however. This week the CIO of the Soros family office wrote to the KWE board expressing her disappointment at the process and the structure of the offer. If the KWE board meets the Soros demand for an open process and a strategic review, there is likely to be a delay in the process at the very least. It also looks possible that a revised offer may be required to secure the takeover, even if a third party does not come forward with a bid. If the board were to decide on an orderly disposal process, which is the other option proposed, that would delay it even further but could be beneficial to shareholders in the long run.

Market Tech to be bought by parent

The Analyst

About Mark Cartlich

Mark Cartlich

Mark Cartlich is a director of Argento Capital Markets, a boutique corporate advisory firm specialising in the property sector, established in 2012. He started his career with Coopers & Lybrand after graduating from Cambridge University. He joined Baring Securities in 1993 and after the takeover by ING he built up the EMEA Real Estate team, which was top rated by Extel in 2008. He moved to Nomura Securities in the same year, as Head of the Property and Infrastructure Research team across global emerging markets and was subsequently the Head of GEMs Property and Infrastructure Research at Religare Capital Markets from 2009 to 2012. After two years covering property and infrastructure companies at the independent research firm Edison, he moved to Sanlam Securities’ UK broking business as Head of the Property and Infrastructure team, before joining Argento in 2016.

Articles by Mark Cartlich

Subscribe to our print magazine now!