S&P 500 CAPE ratio says the US index is in an epic bubble – The Property Chronicle
Select your region of interest:

Real estate, alternative real assets and other diversions

S&P 500 CAPE ratio says the US index is in an epic bubble

Investor's Notebook

Following the crash of 2008/2009 the S&P 500 went on a record-breaking run, gaining around 400% over 11 years before peaking in early 2020.

It then suffered a record-breaking crash thanks to Covid-19, but that was short-lived and the US large-cap index is now setting all-time highs on a regular basis.

At the time of writing the S&P 500 is just below 4,200, which is fractionally below its recently set all-time high. So, the price is high on a historical basis, but so is its valuation according to the CAPE ratio.

Valuing the S&P 500 using its CAPE ratio

If you’re not familiar with the cyclically adjusted PE ratio (CAPE) then here’s a quick summary.

When we value an index, we’re effectively trying to work out if the price is high or low compared to the index’s fair value, ie, the price a rational investor would pay to get their target rate of return.

So we’re trying to compare price to value.

Since nobody knows the true value of an index, we have to make an estimate based on conservative but realistic assumptions.

With the standard PE ratio we’re comparing price to earnings, so we’re using earnings as a proxy for value. If earnings go up then we assume value goes up too, and that’s a reasonable assumption.

But PE only looks at last year’s earnings and earnings in a single year can be very volatile. Intrinsic or fair value, on the other hand, usually isn’t volatile.

For example, if Tesco earns zero profit in a year, it wouldn’t be reasonable to say that Tesco’s fair value was zero.

Obviously the S&P 500’s earnings are more stable than most companies’ and they probably won’t go to zero anytime soon, but they’re still somewhat volatile as the chart below shows.

By cyclically adjusting earnings (using their inflation adjusted 10-year average) we get something that’s more stable and more closely related to the fair or intrinsic value of these 500 companies:

Investor's Notebook

About John Kingham

John Kingham

John Kingham is the founder of UKDividendStocks.com, the membership website for sensible long-term dividend investors. John's approach to high yield, low risk investing is to buy quality dividend stocks when there is a significant margin of safety between price and fair value. John is also the author of The Defensive Value Investor: A Complete Step-By-Step Guide to Building a High Yield, Low Risk Share Portfolio. His website can be found at: www.ukvalueinvestor.com.

Articles by John Kingham

Subscribe to our magazine now!